The Media Is Driving A Mental Depression

I feel bad for millions of people. Since October 2008 a collective watching and waiting has been going on. More people are thinking “stocks” then ever before. People tuned in to hear Bush promise to solve the markets, to make their money back, now they hang on every word from Obama as a way to recoup losses. People are watching news more now and none of it is happy news. Which brings me to my big picture point: the media is playing a role in making the country sick – mentally sick. They are whipping everyone into a frenzy. There is a nationwide depression unfolding, and I don’t mean the economic kind. The media is depressing people with one day great news, the next day bad news, and acting like that kind of hysterical up then down reporting is responsible. It’s not. How can this organized effort by every media player (and they are all guilty) not have a detrimental effect on mental health of people? Someone might say, “You are doing the same thing Covel!” I don’t think so. I am trying to come at this from an honest vantage, to give people a way out, not deliver more pre-packaged talking points or nonsensical right/left baloney.

Interestingly, I found this from October 10, 2008:

Anyway, do you think the news is exacerbating people’s depression and fear about the economy? Do you have any examples in your own hometown of similar experiences where people are staying home, bailing out or just plain frightened of what is going on, way beyond what is called for? I really think the media is driving much of the bad news out there. People may be right to be frugal at the moment, but I wonder if Obama wins how long afterward the positive media spin on the economy will take. I recently read that more people are going to therapists over the economy etc. recently. If Obama gets elected, will it be like national Prozac for the media?

The media fear factor is worse now with Obama in! And it is accelerating it appears!

  • http://michaelcovel.com Michael Covel

    Don’t read me wrong the economy is atrocious, but scaring the living shit out of people every day, day after day, while offering no solution except “government”, is perverse.

  • Mel

    Agreed that the economy is atrocious, but I think that people have the power to turn the TV off and or stop reading the paper. The way the media “makes” people feel exponentially happy when things are going great is the same practice as the opposite. Letting the media or others influence you says more about you than them.

    The solution is within all of us…but that’s not the American dream is it? Well I believe it will have to be as we evolve through this situation.

  • Andrew
  • Martin Hernandez

    Getting sick is bad, but the ones who are not sick yet are getting so confused that they don’t trust anyone. Guys like Jim Cramer and the rest CNBC’s friends should be off the air immediately.

  • http://www.tltblog.com Ladi

    I’ve been on a media brake for a week now; no watching the news, no reading any news related material on the internet, and it feels so good. I agree…it’s pretty overwhelming following the media nowadays.

  • Robert Wolf

    True, absolutely true! And the reason is Americans aren´t used to this type of crisis, it´s the story of the moment, it´s NEW.
    I live in a country in South America that´s been in “crisis” for the last 30 years (as more than half of the world has been). President´s get ousted every couple of years, oil (our main export) fluctuates like hell, foreign debt crushes the economy…but we´re used to it, it´s not news anymore. So, we just keep pushing through. Bottom line is it doesn´t really affect our entreprenurial efforts, there is always a way, just have to be creative enough. It´s hard at first, but when you stop paying attention to the crisis news and government reactions and start focusing on the thing you can do, which are work, invent, produce, create, invest, risk, try…things start to fall into place by themselves. The lonesome, passionate entrepreneur is the answer, and he can´t afford to be hanging on every word uttered in cnn…

  • Lamont

    Reporting negative news is just more profitable then reporting positive news. Research has show that negative news segments cause more physiological arousal then positive new segments and negative feelings will outweigh positive ones. More atrocious and barbaric news segments generally lead to higher TV ratings thereby increasing adverting dollars I believe. Check out Ed Seykota (structure of the mind) on his Trading Tribe website to learn how information enters the mind can affect a persons trading judgment….

    (WC)
    http://www.psu.edu/dept/medialab/research/negnews.html
    http://www.seykota.com/tribe/TT_Process/index.htm

  • http://pages.sbcglobal.net/acom Ken – Today’s Breakout Stocks

    Most people feel fear because they don’t have a plan.

  • Steven

    Im right there with you. They need to turn off all the news stop reading everything that is related to the economy. All it does is put these people into deeper depression. Misery loves company. If they didn’t report negative news the ratings would fall though the roof.

  • Raj

    I used to get sick watching CNBC (headache at the end of the day) BEFORE this crisis broke. I have gladly switched CNBC off, as well as other news channels. I pick and choose what news i want to follow. I use a rule of thumb that if the news is important enough it will flow down to me (this is not an original line though!)

    Though people have the power to switch the TV off, fear is a powerful emotion forcing us to keep it on. The majority cannot/will not/not even think of turning the TV off.

  • http://QuotingBobPrechter paul

    “there is in fact a theory that does not need to be reworked, much less play catch-up for years. Elliott wave theory anticipates turns in psychology at several degrees of trend — and what’s unfolding now involves a very large degree of trend.

    Put in the simplest terms, our collective psychology turned from positive to negative. That’s the theory. I hasten to add that the theory is sound and correct not because we say so, but because of the evidence — in other words, the theory becomes visible in practice.

    Our application of the theory says this economic turn is larger than any living adult American has seen (unless you’re around 100), thus evidence for the theory should include large-scale economic events that nobody has seen before. Like what? Well, like a very large bear market in stocks plus a very large national decline in real estate values, that is happening at the same time.

    There are other examples, but the simultaneous collapse in stock and real estate alone amounts to an epochal turn. It’s a crash in collective wealth.”

  • Mitch

    Media is in the business of selling media, plain and simple. “The Medium is the Message”… now more than ever.

  • Raj

    The problem with Elliott wave theory is it is “imprecise”. In bear markets the psychology will always fit into some large degree correction wave. U have to apply the theory yourself to realize that there are plenty of alternate wave counts. Currently we could be in a wave 1 of a very large degree wave 4 correction (this wave spanning centuries), or we could simply be in a cycle degree wave 4 spanning decades, where stocks will fluctuate between the recent highs and lows (or a bit lower) for a couple of decades. It is very easy to buy this theory when we are in so much negative psychology.

    It works perfectly in back testing only. Too many alternate counts to give solid predictions.

  • http://comcast Len

    The media – print, television and the internet – have become so fixated on the economic depression-like atmosphere in the country that it is hard to “tune it out” unless you do just that – “tune it out”. We all have the ability to think and reason independent of media influences. Our problem is and has been that we enjoy being “spoon fed” our news and absorbing too much information. Information overload can only be negated by independent thought that focuses on what we belive is pertinent and necessary to our lives – be it from a financial standpoint or a daily living standpoint. In the present situation “too little” is better than “too much”.

  • Mark Mueller

    The American people have every right to be afraid. This time the media may actually be serving a purpose. The American people are beginning to do the right thing in a crisis such as this: they are beginning to save & pay down debt. The banks are beginning to do the right thing they are tightening credit by raising qualifications and keeping interest rates high.
    It is only our Government that is doing the wrong thing by trying to stimulate the economy artificially by using credit and the printing presses.
    This crisis was caused by credit and may die by it and bring down the whole nation in the process.
    We should know from history that asset bubbles can only be cured by time and belt tightening. Continuing to borrow will only turn the crisis into a catastrophe!!!
    We have seen what that final catastrophe can bring; in Germany it brought hyperinflation and Hitler In the Soviet Union it brought down the government. The examples go on & on but the lesson is always the same; LIVE WITHIN YOUR MEANS whether you are an individual, a business or a government. It seems to me that we are jumping off the cliff into the abyss.


Trend Following

Learn trend following now with our firm.

 

Free Brand new to trend following trading?
Free resources are an immediate starting point for your trading education.

Explore

Premium Need to take your trading to the next level?
15+ years of access & research brings you the chance for outsized absolute returns.

Get Started

Switch to our mobile site